Noir Couture Waterproof

Wonderful mascara!! it's the second time i bought it, i love it!!!!

Blonde-Lash people rejoice!

My fav mascara. I have short blonde lashes and between curling my lashes and two coats of this stuff you’re set for long beautiful lashes. I gave it 4 stars because it is difficult to get the waterproof formula all the way off at times.

My favorite mascara! People ask me if I'm wearing fake lashes. I haven't had a problem with it flaking either.

Disappointing

The wand is far too large, and the product is clumpy. Given the price, I felt I had been completely hoodwinked - I expected a luxury product.

Yes, I wore it during my deployment

I bought this when I was on leave from deployment. I’ve tossed so many mascaras away because they couldn’t withstand the heat, and would melt off of my lashes in 110 degrees. But this would withstand the heat, and humidity. It’s a pain to take off when you don’t have make up remover, so user BEWARE. I don’t use it everyday, but I’m not disappointed whenever I do wear it.

I bought this for my son’s wedding on recommendation from Sephora staff. I found the applicator slightly difficult to use when applying mascara and ended up using a spare wand to separate my lashes. It is waterproof, thank goodness. Removal was not difficult.

Would be a great mascara if it didn’t make you have raccoon eyes.

Disappointed

Very disappointed. They were out of the phenomenon so I bought the noir. It comes off the top of your eyelashes and leaves black marks under your brows.

I love the brush the mascara takes like 5 mins to dry but so far it makes my lashes look fuller and it keeps them separated.

I will have to agree with all the other one star reviews. This product is NOT smudge proof. What it is, makeup remover proof. I could not get it off easily (even after trying two different waterproof mascara removers). It's too bad because I love Phenomen’Eyes Waterproof Mascara.

Bulky Brush

Brush is too big. Difficulty in application without smudging as the brush size is too bulky. Only had it on for 3 hrs and already smudged under my eyes.

Personal favorite

I have short and very straight lashes. They usually either stick together or droop down. This is the only mascara that never gets clumpy for me, it lifts my lashes and they stay up whereas all other mascaras are too heavy. I do use a curler always but with this my lashes hold their curl the longest.